Records Home Schools ranked in the AP top 10 five times or more
 Records for all divisions/classes since AP rankings began in 1985
       School times  Comments
1 Pickerington* 17 I (15), AAA (2)
2 Berlin Hiland   15   IV
2 Beavercreek   15   I
4 Millersburg West Holmes 14 I (11), AA (3)
5 Garfield Hts. Trinity 13 IV (4), III (8), II (1)
5 Youngstown Boardman 13 I (12), AAA (1)
7 South Charleston Southeastern 11 IV
8 Zanesville Rosecrans 10 IV (8), A (1), AA (1)
8 Dayton Chaminade-Julienne 10 I (7), II (3)
8 South Euclid Regina 10 III
8 Versailles 10 III
12 Columbus Brookhaven 9 III (8), AAA (1)
12 Kalida 9 IV (8), A (1)
12 Toledo Central Catholic 9 I (8), AAA (1)
15 Cleve. VASJ 8 II (3), III (5)
15 Wadsworth 8 I
15 Wooster 8 I
15 Ottoville 8 IV
19 Barberton 7 I (5), AAA (2)
19 Beloit West Branch 7 II (6), AA (1)
19 Canton McKinley 7 I (4), AAA (3)
19 Maria Stein Marion Local 7 IV
19 Rocky River Magnificat 7 I
19 Cin. Mt Notre Dame 7 I (6), AAA (1)
19 East Canton 7 IV
19 North Canton Hoover 7 I
27 Avon Lake 6 I (1), II (4), III (1)
27 Bascom Hopewell-Loudon 6 IV
27 Castalia Margaretta 6 III (5), AA (1)
27 Cin. Princeton 6 I (5), AAA(1)
27 Copley 6 II
27 Danville 6 IV
27 Hamler Patrick Henry 6 III (3), IV (3)
27 Heath 6 III
27 Minster 6 IV
27 Oak Hill 6 III
27 Shelby 6 II
27 Lima Bath 6 II (4), AA (1)
27 McDonald 6 IV
27 Sugarcreek Garaway 6 III (4), IV (2)
27 Warsaw River View 6 II (4), AA (1)
42 Coldwater 5 III (4), AA (1)
42 Jackson Center 5 IV
42 Logan 5 I (4), II (1)
42 Mansfield St. Peter's 5 IV (4), A (1)
42 Middletown Fenwick 5 III (1), IV (3), A (1)
42 New Riegel 5 IV
42 New Washington Buckeye Central 5 IV (2), A (2), AA (1)
42 Pemberville Eastwood 5 II (3), III (2)
42 Sherwood Fairview 5 III
42 Springfield Kenton Ridge 5 II (3), III (2)
42 Upper Scioto Valley 5 IV (4), A (1)
42 Bellaire St. John's 5 IV
42 Canfield 5 II(4), AA (1)
42 Delphos St. John's 5 III(1), IV(2), A(1)
42 Kettering Alter 5 II
*Pickerington HS is no longer in existence; it has split into Pickerington North and Pickerington Central